Rachel Hocking
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
    • Calendar
    • Contact
  • Teaching
    • Piano students >
      • Junior
      • Beginner
      • Intermediate
      • Advanced
    • School Music
  • 2021 Timetable

can technology replace teachers?

23/4/2016

0 Comments

 
I've seen a few interesting videos recently that show in an exciting and innovative way just how technology can be used in education. Each video, such as Mitra's engaging presentation on his concept of a 'School in the Cloud', would make it seem that teachers in the traditional sense are no longer needed. This is not true. Teachers are leaders in pedagogy and any technology success in educational settings only comes from their skill in choosing and implementing it as needed. For me, any incorporation of technology in a music course must enhance the musical output and so I see technology as a tool that teachers can use, rather than an outcome in itself.

Informal pedagogies in music education and their incorporation of technology tend to set themselves up around pop music. One article by Don Leblar on the master-less studio is an example. However, I am worried that informal pedagogies that validate and promote pop music methods may lead to more pop music, rather than artistic music - yes, there is a difference, and society is becoming less and less aware of the difference. Any technology used in education needs to support the type of music being studied. Informal pedagogies can be used across all types of music education, because they are informal, but they will not necessarily lead to musical mastery and skill. 
 
Below is my 'creative' response that outlines in a practical way my position on technology - a choral composition titled Provocation. In writing this composition, I used the following technology:
- Sibelius 7.5
- an online translator

I used Sibelius to notate my composition. As music teachers, we should be able to call ourselves 'masters' in our discipline. My training in music allowed me to compose the piece, including setting of text, voice leading, choice of key and harmonic progression, and understanding of the instrumentation used. I relied on my ear rather than the software to inform the sound.  All the compositional choices, whether appreciated or not by the listener, are conscious and educated choices. For the text, I used an online translator to translate my thoughts in English to Latin. However, I have no training in Latin so have relied on the translator to do an accurate job for me. I've tried translating the Latin back to English and have found that it makes no sense. Therefore, my conclusion is that technology is only useful as a tool if you know what you're doing in the first place. I need to find a master in Latin. 

The original English text basically is:
"Who writes the information? Who publishes it? Teachers are more than holders-of-knowledge. They inspire, question, encourage, are authentic, passionate, articulate and intellectual. Technology is a tool for lifelong learning but is not something that can model, question, inspire, create passion, demonstrate authenticity, think for itself or articulate what it wants to say. Technology is 0 or 1."

I chose to write this for a choir, not only because it involves text, but also because of my background in the Kodaly method and its reliance on singing, Richard Gill's 'Counterpoint' thoughts and my recent viewing of Wide Open Sky showcasing Michelle Leonard's work with her outback childrens choir. This demonstrates my priority on music-making as an acoustic, living experience, as well as my love for the classical choral tradition. For this reason, I haven't recorded Provocation. The only way to experience it (if you really want to!) is to perform it live with a few other musicians - this can be done in real-time whether in the same room or connected virtually. 

If you can't see the file below, you can download it here.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    My Blog

    Reflections/news on music, piano and music teaching, and anything else that pops up.

    Archives

    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    April 2014
    March 2014
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    February 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012

    Categories

    All
    19th Century
    Advertising Music
    Africa
    Andrew Brown
    Angela Hewitt
    Aretha Franklin
    Arts Issues
    Australian Music
    Baroque
    Childrens Music
    Chopin
    Choral Music
    Classical
    Composition
    Concert
    Congratulations
    Coursera
    David Price
    Dyslexia
    Education
    Eisteddfod
    Electronic Music
    Film
    Gamelan
    Garageband
    Hairspray
    Homebush West
    HSC
    Inclusive Teaching
    Indigenous
    James Humberstone
    Jewish
    John Williams
    Kodaly
    Launchpad
    Links
    Lior
    Mario
    Michelle Leonard
    Midnight Oil
    Minimalism
    Moorambilla Voices
    Mozart
    MTA NSW
    Musical Futures
    Music Council Of Australia
    Music Trust
    Nick Lane
    Nigel Westlake
    Orff Music
    Paella
    Performance
    Piano
    Piano Teaching
    Piano Works
    Pop
    Practise
    Repertoire
    Richard Gill
    Rock
    Romantic
    School Music
    Sibelius
    Soul
    Soundation
    Special Needs
    Stephen Heppell
    Stuart Bowen
    Sugata Mitra
    Sydney Conservatorium Of Music
    Teacher Education
    Teaching Guides
    Technique
    Technology
    Topics
    Virtual Choir
    Wide Open Sky
    Woody
    Workshop
    Yolngu
    Yothu Yindi

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.